The seizure of the Q-tips in this case cannot be upheld under the plain-view exception because their incriminating nature was not apparent without conducting some further search of the Q-tips, i.e ., seizing the Q-tips for further observation and field testing. According to Officer Sage, at a glance, the Q-tips did not appear to be discolored. It was not until they were actually seized that a discoloration was observed. And it was not until the Q-tips were tested that it was clear they were contaminated with methamphetamine. Because of these facts, the plain-view exception does not apply.
Because none of the exceptions to a warrantless search and seizure existed at the time Officer Sage seized the Q-tips and had them tested, the warrantless seizure of the Q-tips was unconstitutional. Thus, the Q-tips found on the coffee table were inadmissible at trial under the exclusionary rule.[Update: the state did not file a PR and the mandate issued on December 1, 2014].]