Fitzgerald was pulled over while traveling by himself in his girlfriend's truck in the late afternoon. He had run a stop sign. Officer R.A. Thatcher discovered that Fitzgerald's driver's license was suspended. Fitzgerald told Thatcher that he had already called his girlfriend to come to the scene and pick up his truck, and he was completely cooperative while Thatcher placed him under arrest. Once Fitzgerald was cuffed and patted down, Thatcher found $2,673 in cash, which Thatcher described as "a mini cash register," when going through Fitzgerald's pockets. This discovery prompted the officer to ask Fitzgerald about his employment. Fitzgerald replied that he earned $10 an hour at a car detailing shop and that the money in his pockets was for rent and bills.
The officer then returned to the girlfriend's truck with the intention of searching it for drug evidence. He did so and found methamphetamine, digital scales, and several small plastic bags inside.
The KSC reviewed the six circumstances the state asserted provided probable cause but found them wanting:
When the totality of all of these circumstances is considered, as it must be, we conclude that the State did not carry its burden of demonstrating the existence of probable cause to support Thatcher's initial search of the truck. Of the factors it cites, most are neutral or helpful to the defense, tending to diffuse suspicion rather than enhance it. Those factors that do contribute to probable cause are weak. The district court should not have relied on the probable cause plus exigent circumstances exception to the warrant requirement to admit the evidence derived from the initial search of the truck.
Here is a Wichita Eagle article reporting on the KSC case.
No comments:
Post a Comment